Explanation
What these questions mean
Yes-no questions with modal verbs ask for a short answer: yes or no. We use them to ask about ability, permission, advice, future, possibility, or obligation. For example, "Can you swim?" asks about ability, and "Should we leave now?" asks for advice. In Japanese, you may say 〜できますか, 〜してもいいですか, or 〜したほうがいいですか. English uses a modal verb at the start of the question.
How to build them
The order is modal + subject + base verb. Do not use "do" or "does". Do not put "to" before the verb.
- "Can I open the window?"
- "Will she call later?"
- "Should we wait?"
After the modal, use the base verb: "go", "come", "help", not "to go" or "goes".
Choosing the right modal
"Can" is common for ability or informal permission. "Could" is softer and more polite: "Could you help me?" "Will" asks about the future or a decision: "Will it rain?" "Would" is often used for polite requests. "Should" asks for advice. "May" is more formal for permission: "May I sit here?" "Must I...?" is grammatical, but in everyday English people often say "Do I have to...?" instead.
Negative questions and answers
The negative comes from the modal: "can't", "won't", "shouldn't", "mustn't". The word order stays the same: "Can't you stay?" "Shouldn't we go?"
In short answers, repeat the modal: "Yes, I can." "No, I can't." In English, the answer should match the real meaning, not just "yes" or "no".
Conversation
A: "Can you help me with this email?"
B: "Yes, I can. Should I make it shorter?"
A: "Yes, please. Will you send it before lunch?"
B: "Sure. Can I check the grammar first?"
A: "Of course."
Examples
- Can I sit here? ここに座ってもいいですか?
- Could you help me with this bag? このかばん、手伝ってくれますか?
- Will it rain tomorrow? 明日は雨が降りますか?
- Should we call her now? 今、彼女に電話したほうがいいですか?
- May I ask a question? 質問してもよろしいですか?
- No, I can't come today. いいえ、今日は行けません。
Common Mistakes
1. Using "do" with a modal
Wrong: "Do you can swim?"
Right: "Can you swim?"
Modal verbs do not use do/does in questions.
2. Putting "to" after the modal
Wrong: "Should I to call her?"
Right: "Should I call her?"
After a modal, use the base verb only.
3. Using the wrong word order
Wrong: "You will come tomorrow?"
Right: "Will you come tomorrow?"
In English, the modal comes before the subject.
4. Using "must I...?" in everyday speech
Less natural: "Must I pay now?"
Right: "Do I have to pay now?"
"Must I...?" is grammatical, but "Do I have to...?" is more natural in daily English.