Negatives with Modal Verbs

A2 Eiken Pre-2 Beginner

modal + not + base verb; modal + subject + base verb?

Explanation

What modal negatives mean

Modal verbs like can, must, should, will, may, and might show ability, rules, advice, future meaning, or possibility. In English, the negative is usually made with not after the modal. Japanese often uses one negative form, like 〜ない, for many of these meanings, but English chooses a different modal to show the exact idea.

How the form works

  • modal + not + base verb: "You can't park here."
  • Short forms are very common in speaking: can't, won't, mustn't, shouldn't, couldn't.
  • Do not use do/does/did with a modal: not "He doesn't can swim."
  • "Cannot" is the more formal written form of "can't".

Main meanings

"Can't" is the most common. It can mean not able, not allowed, or impossible. "Mustn't" means a strong rule or prohibition: "You mustn't touch that." "Shouldn't" means it is a bad idea or not the right thing: "You shouldn't drive if you're tired." "Couldn't" is the past form, so it talks about inability in the past. "Won't" means will not. It can show a refusal or a future negative. "May not" and "might not" mean it is possible that something will not happen: "She might not come."

Don't mix up "mustn't" and "don't have to"

"Mustn't" means "not allowed". "Don't have to" means "not necessary". This is an important difference for Japanese learners. English separates these meanings more clearly than Japanese does. Compare "You mustn't open this door." (it is not allowed) with "You don't have to bring lunch." (it is optional).

Questions and negative questions

In questions, put the modal before the subject: "Can I sit here?" If the question is negative, it often sounds surprised, upset, or persuasive: "Can't you wait a minute?" When you ask about obligation, English usually prefers "Do I have to...?" rather than "Must I...?"

Conversation

A: We can't park here.
B: Really? Can we park over there?
A: Yes, but you mustn't park on the yellow line.
B: Okay. We don't have to pay after 6, right?

Examples

  • You can't park here. ここは駐車できません。
  • You mustn't touch that. それに触ってはいけません。
  • You don't have to bring lunch. 昼食を持っていく必要はありません。
  • You shouldn't drive if you're tired. 疲れているなら、運転しないほうがいいです。
  • Can I sit here? ここに座ってもいいですか。
  • Can't you wait a minute? ちょっと待てないの。

Common Mistakes

1. Using "do" with a modal verb

Wrong: "I don't can swim."
Right: "I can't swim."

Modal verbs do not take do/does/did. Use the modal itself.

2. Adding "to" after a modal

Wrong: "You mustn't to smoke here."
Right: "You mustn't smoke here."

After a modal, use the base verb only.

3. Mixing up "mustn't" and "don't have to"

Wrong (lunch is optional): "You mustn't bring lunch."
Right: "You don't have to bring lunch."

"Mustn't" means not allowed. "Don't have to" means not necessary.

Ready to practice? Try a quick fill-in-the-blank quiz on this grammar point.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.