Explanation
What a subject question means
A subject question asks about the person or thing that does the action. The question word is the subject of the sentence, so the verb comes after it. English uses this when the speaker wants to know the doer, not the object.
How to build it
Put the question word first, then use the verb. Do not use do/does/did just to make a subject question.
- "Who called you?"
- "What happened?"
- "Which bus goes to the station?"
- "Who is knocking?"
- "Who isn't coming?"
- "Which cup is yours?"
The question word takes the subject place, so the word order stays simple. Use the tense you need in the verb.
Who, what, and which
Who is for people. What is for things, events, or ideas. Which is for a choice from a small group. Use which when you already know the set and want one item from it.
Negative forms and Japanese contrast
For negatives, use the normal negative form of be or the main verb. The question word still stays first. Japanese often feels similar here, because Japanese also puts the question word in the subject place, but English learners sometimes add do/does/did because other question types need them. Subject questions do not use that extra question order.
Conversation
A: Who is waiting outside?
B: Ken is. Who isn't here yet?
A: My boss isn't here yet.
B: What is going on?
Examples
- Who called you? だれが電話してきたのですか。
- What happened? 何が起きたのですか。
- Which bus goes to the station? どのバスが駅へ行きますか。
- Who is knocking? だれがノックしているのですか。
- Who isn't coming? だれが来ないのですか。
- Which cup is yours? どのカップがあなたのですか。
Common Mistakes
1. Adding do/does/did in a subject question
Wrong: "Who did called you?"
Right: "Who called you?"
When the question word is the subject, do-support is not used.
2. Putting the subject in the wrong place
Wrong: "Who you helped?" (when you want to know the person who helped you)
Right: "Who helped you?"
The question word is the subject, so it comes right before the verb, and "you" comes after the verb.
3. Using what for a person
Wrong: "What called you?"
Right: "Who called you?"
Use who for people. Use what for things or events.