Using "cannot" for Logical Impossibility

B2 Eiken Pre-1 Intermediate

subject + cannot/can't + base verb

Explanation

What "cannot" means

We use "cannot" to say that something is impossible. It is not a guess. It is a strong conclusion from the facts. In everyday speech, people usually say "can't." "Cannot" is more common in writing and in formal English.

For this meaning, "cannot" is close to Japanese "ありえない" or "はずがない". The idea is: the speaker looks at the situation and decides that the thing cannot be true.

How to build it

  • subject + cannot + base verb
  • subject + can't + base verb

Use the base verb after "cannot". Do not add "to". For example: "It cannot be true." "She can't be the manager." "That cannot be Ken; he is in Osaka."

With "be", the meaning is often very clear. "He can't be at home" means the speaker is sure he is not at home, because the facts do not fit.

Cannot vs. can, and why the meaning is special

Be careful: "can" usually means ability or possibility, not logical impossibility. So "He can be at home" does not mean "He must be at home." For logical impossibility, use "cannot" or "can't".

Also, do not confuse this with "mustn't." "Mustn't" usually means "not allowed." "Can't" here means "impossible." Those two ideas are different.

Questions and the opposite idea

This grammar is usually used in statements. If you want to ask about possibility, use "can": "Can he really be at home already?" If you are surprised, you can also ask "Can't he be at home already?" But that sounds emotional, not neutral.

English often uses this modal form where Japanese uses "はずがない" or "ありえない". Japanese does not need a special verb change for this idea, but English usually shows the speaker's judgment with "can't" or "cannot".

Extra practice sentences

  • "The train cannot be here yet; it left only five minutes ago."
  • "She can't be your sister; you look nothing alike."
  • "They cannot know the answer yet."
  • "Can he really be the new teacher?"
  • "This can't happen twice in one week."
  • "That cannot be her phone; hers is on the desk."

Conversation

A: Why is the office still dark?
B: It can't be open yet. The sign says ten o'clock.
A: Then nobody is inside?
B: No, they cannot be there at this hour.
A: So our meeting hasn't started yet?
B: Right. It cannot start before ten.

Examples

  • The train cannot be late; it left on time. その電車が遅れているはずがありません。定刻に出発しました。
  • She can't be your sister; you look nothing alike. 彼女があなたのお姉さんのはずがありません。全然似ていません。
  • They cannot know the answer yet. 彼らはまだ答えを知っているはずがありません。
  • Can he really be the new teacher? 彼が本当に新しい先生なのですか。
  • This can't happen twice in one week. こんなことが1週間に2回も起こるはずがありません。
  • That cannot be her phone; hers is on the desk. あれが彼女の電話のはずがありません。彼女のは机の上にあります。

Common Mistakes

1. Using "can" when the meaning is impossible

Wrong: "He can be at home. I just saw him on the bus."
Right: "He cannot be at home. I just saw him on the bus."

Use "cannot" or "can't" when the facts make the idea impossible.

2. Adding "to" after "cannot"

Wrong: "It cannot to be true."
Right: "It cannot be true."

After "cannot", use the base verb. Do not put "to" before it.

3. Using "don't can" or "doesn't can"

Wrong: "She doesn't can be the owner."
Right: "She can't be the owner."

Modal verbs like "can" do not use do-support.

4. Using "mustn't" for logical impossibility

Wrong: "He mustn't be at home; his car is gone."
Right: "He can't be at home; his car is gone."

"Mustn't" usually means "not allowed," not "impossible."

Ready to practice? Try a quick fill-in-the-blank quiz on this grammar point.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.